· MIND
The Curse of Knowledge. Why experts explain badly, and prompts fail the same way
01
Tapping songs
In 1990 Elizabeth Newton, a Stanford graduate student, had people tap out well-known songs while a listener guessed the tune. Tappers predicted listeners would get about half. They got roughly one in forty.
Tappers heard the melody in their heads. Listeners heard knocking.
02
The name
Colin Camerer, George Loewenstein and Martin Weber named the effect in 1989: informed people struggle to reason as if they knew less, even when it pays to.
Steven Pinker called it the main cause of bad writing. Experts skip steps they no longer notice, use terms they forgot learning, and omit the example that would make it click.
03
Prompting is the same
A model is a listener who hears only knocking. You know the codebase, the customer, the goal and the ten things you tried. It knows the prompt.
Most bad agent output I see is the curse of knowledge, transferred.
04
What helps
Test on a real outsider, not a colleague. Give an example before the abstraction. Write the obvious step: it is obvious only to you.
The curse lifts with feedback, not effort. You learn what you left out when someone fails to understand it.